Fishing success isn’t just about having the right rod and reel—it’s also about using the best bait for your target species. Whether you’re going after tuna, striped bass, or fluke, knowing what bait works best in New Jersey’s waters can make all the difference.
One of the first decisions an angler has to make is whether to use live bait or artificial lures. Both have their advantages:
Live Bait offers natural scent and movement, making it highly effective for predatory fish.
Artificial Lures mimic baitfish and can be used in a variety of conditions with great success.
Striped bass are opportunistic feeders that go after a variety of live baits and lures.
Best Live Baits: Bunker (Menhaden), Eels, Sandworms
Best Artificial Lures: Swimbaits, Topwater Poppers, Bucktail Jigs
These bottom-dwelling fish prefer baits that stay near the ocean floor.
Best Live Baits: Killifish, Squid Strips, Spearing
Best Artificial Lures: Gulp! Soft Plastics, Jigging Spoons
Tuna are aggressive predators that respond well to a mix of live bait and chunking techniques.
Best Live Baits: Butterfish, Sardines, Squid
Best Artificial Lures: Topwater Poppers, Trolling Plugs, Metal Jigs
Mahi are visual feeders that strike brightly colored baits and lures.
Best Live Baits: Live Pilchards, Ballyhoo
Best Artificial Lures: Chugger Heads, Trolling Squid Lures
Water clarity and temperature can also affect bait choice:
Clear Water: Bright-colored lures and fast-moving live bait tend to work best.
Murky Water: Heavily scented baits like bunker or squid are more effective.
Cold Water: Slower presentations with bait like eels or jigs can entice sluggish fish.
Always check local fishing reports to see what bait is working best.
Experiment with different bait types to see what the fish prefer on any given day.
Keep your bait fresh—live bait should be lively, and cut bait should be firm and not overly soft.
Not sure what bait to use? Let the experts at Golden Eagle guide you to success. Our experienced crew knows exactly what works best for each species and will help you land the big one.
Call us at (732) 681-6144 to book your fishing adventure today!
